HR Department
  • Home
  • Did you Know?
  • Our Services
    • NEW: Mediation
    • HR Audit
    • Implementation
    • HR Support Service
    • HR Services
  • Our Experts
  • Testimonials
  • The HR Advisor
  • Contact Us
  • Login

Employee Performance Reviews: Productive or Destructive?

20/7/2015

2 Comments

 
Picture
Most companies have yearly performance reviews in December/January or mid-year and unfortunately a lot of businesses only start pulling information on employees a few days in advance. Managers hate it and staff members get uptight about what they will hear, which often leads to stress leading up to the meeting and a feeling of disappointment or dissatisfaction afterwards.

If you Google ‘performance review’, a few thousand results will be returned on advice for how employees should prepare for their review, however it’s vital for employers to do their preparation as well.

No matter what industry or type of business, staff members want to have a formal review so they know if they are doing their job to the employer’s satisfaction. The majority of employees can see when managers have put an effort into reviewing their performance and shown an interest in their career development.

This week I want to highlight the not so nice side of employee performance reviews and how managers can start considering how this year’s review will be different than the years preceding it.


Why is the ‘normal’ employee performance review so wrong?

A common misconception about performance reviews is that they are focused on the employee’s performance within the last six months to a year. This shouldn’t be the case. Staff reviews should give employers a chance to evaluate how they run their business, by letting employees voice their opinions, grow and hopefully become better team members.

Reviews are often held once or twice a year and often by a member of the management team who doesn’t necessarily work with or closely to the employee on a daily basis. The infrequency of the reviews by someone who doesn’t usually liaise with the employee leads to the feeling of ‘obligation’ rather than it being a normal part of the job.

Quite often in bigger companies, the scoring system is generalised across multiple departments. This causes an issue as every staff member is being judged in the same manner, regardless of their working differences and job responsibilities.

Whilst it’s understandable that recent happenings in one’s mind stand out the most, it’s one of the biggest downfalls of performance reviews. The ‘Recency Effect’ causes managers to focus on a recent event, positive or negative, and use this as a marker of an employee’s performance instead of reviewing their performance over the entire period. Employees who know this often ensure they are the best they can be in the run up to a review.

In smaller companies, feedback might only be based on one person’s perspective. If there is only one Director and a team of five employees, it can be hard for the MD to not be biased. Without collaboration, the feedback can be subjective and not offer a full picture of employee performance.

Employee performance reviews are more often than not closely linked to salary and potential pay rises. This leads to stress for the employee who focuses on the outcome as well as the employer who may not be offering a pay rise. In turn, this devalues the process of the review, giving feedback and improving performance.

With those points in mind, I’ve included some tips below for employers and managers to help them prepare for conducting a successful performance review.


What changes should be made to the current employee performance review?

Apart from changes to the annual or twice yearly review, it’s imperative for employers to give feedback as situations occur, rather than wait until review time. Everyone responds more positively to immediate feedback, and in doing so, employees can work on their performance each day instead of being loaded with information once or twice a year.

With regards to the performance review, the process should go as follows:

Job Description

I’ve mentioned before about how important it is for employers to refer back to individual job descriptions and here is no different. The document should provide information on the employee’s duties of their role and standards they are expected to achieve. As this should have been issued when the employee first started working at the company, both the employer and staff member should have a copy and refer to it during the review.

Before the Performance Review

Each employee should be given a self-appraisal form to fill out before their individual review. This enables the employer to receive information on how the employee rates their performance within the company and any issues they may like to be addressed. Employers should these out at least three to four weeks before the review and should be returned no later than a week before. This gives the employee plenty of time to prepare for the review and the employer a sufficient period to prepare comments and areas for discussion.

Questions could include:

  • What have been your main accomplishments over the last six months/year?
  • Which actions concern you most or disappoint you?
  • Do you feel you have developed any skills or overcome weaknesses in the last six months/year?
  • Do you feel you and your manager communicate well? What changes would you like to see moving forward?
  • What are your top three priories for the next six months?
  • Is there anything about the company you would like to see improved or do you have any ideas on how you could see certain aspects of the business working differently?

Environment

Employers should focus on where the review will take place and the time allocated to it. All meetings should be in a private location where there will be no interruptions, such as phone calls or other work related distractions and a positive atmosphere will more than likely create a positive communication. More than enough time needs to be considered so employees don’t feel they are being rushed through the review or feeling undervalued as a team member.

The Review

Many employers go down ‘the sandwich review’ route which means they give positive feedback to start, then negative feedback, and finish on positive feedback. This doesn’t work, as the initial positive feedback will feel insincere and the employee won’t listen to the follow up positives as they will be focusing on the negative feedback.

Instead, employers should focus on the positives to begin with. Anything the employee has achieved or is doing well in should be mentioned. Praise needs to be offered where it is due and if the employee has been in the company for a few years, then they should be told how they have improved since their last review.

Negatives, although they are not nice, need to be addressed. If the employee is lacking in certain areas or hasn’t achieved goals that had been previously set out, the employer needs to inform them of this. It’s imperative to be specific and mention exact goals and instances where the employee has underperformed so it doesn’t seem like a generalisation or make the employee feel they are underachieving in their role overall.

Get Feedback and Set Goals

Employees should be offered the chance to voice their opinion and give feedback. Employers need to ask the staff member how they might improve on their own performance and ask what they can do to help them achieve it. This will give the employer better insight into whether the employee needs more training or possibly alter their role somehow.

Setting new goals and sticking to them is an important part of performance reviews, otherwise they are a waste of time. Employees need to commit to improving on their weaknesses and progressing even more in the following months. Goals should be written down and signed by both the employer and employee as the document will be used at the following review.

Finish on a Positive Note

Every appraisal for each employee will be different, however it’s important to always end on a positive note, whether the review was good or poor. Employers need to ensure the employee knows they will do what they can to help them meet objectives in the months following the meeting.

Always Follow Up

The most important step of the review process is to follow up on the commitments made to the employee. If an employer has stated they will help an under-performer, they need to speak to a supervisor and ensure steps are being taken to aid them in their role.

This isn’t just for the employee’s benefit, but also to protect the employer. If a business has to terminate employment, there must be evidence that the employer has given the employee an opportunity to improve their performance. If this is not apparent, the company could be left open to a claim of unfair dismissal.

When a performance review is well prepared for and properly conducted, it assists an employer in seeing which of its staff members are making the most valuable contribution and which are letting the side down – useful information to have in today’s tough business climate, where every euro must count.



The contents of this article are necessarily expressed in broad terms and limited to general information rather than detailed analyses or legal advice. Specialist professional advice should always be obtained to address legal and other issues arising in specific contexts.

2 Comments
Peter Brewer link
16/7/2018 05:44:49 am

Well, performance assessment is one of the most cardinal communication stuffs an establishment can implement. It is a task that should not be complicated. Rather I feel that it's a task that has to be executed properly. It is advantageous both for the chairperson and his hired helps. It is the moment to give some vital response, reorganize the standard of performance, and set some anticipations for the future job accomplishments. I think it is the most effective way to make some candid conversations about the performance deficiencies so that well-regulated steps can be taken for the improvement.

Reply
professional development plan UK link
23/12/2021 12:28:14 am

Ongoing training can also be a great way of ensuring every member of the workforce is up to the same standard, in terms of their skills, knowledge and so on.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014

    Categories

    All
    Absenteeism
    Agile Management
    Anger
    Annual Leave
    Appointments
    Big Data
    Bullying
    Bullying In The Workplace
    Business
    BYOD
    Collaboration
    Communication
    Company Culture
    Compulsory Retirement
    Conflict Resolution
    Corporate Culture
    Covid 19
    Covid-19
    Cyber Bullying
    Data Protection
    Device Policy
    Digital
    Digital Transformation
    Disciplinary Procedures
    Discrimination
    Diversity
    Dress Code
    Emotional Intelligence
    Employee Benefits
    Employee Diversity
    Employee Engagement
    Employee Performance
    Employee Relations
    Employee Resignation
    Employee Retention
    Employee Rights
    Employee Wellbeing
    Employer Branding
    Employment Contract
    Equality
    Flexible Working Hours
    Freelance
    Freelancer Management
    Freelancing
    Gender
    Gig Economy
    Health And Safety
    Hiring Process
    HR
    HR Automation
    HRLocker
    HR Paper Work
    HR Performance
    HR Tips
    Human Resources
    Incentives
    Inclusion
    Independent Contractor
    In-house
    Innovation
    Intelectual Property
    Intern
    Jargon
    Just Culture
    L&D
    Leadership
    Learning & Development
    Long Term Illness
    Management
    Managers
    McDonalds
    Mediation
    Mentorship
    Millenials
    Motivating Staff
    Music
    Negative Employees
    Office Romance
    Onboarding
    Outsourced HR
    Paid Paternity Benefit
    Parental Leave
    Parenting
    Part Time
    Part-time
    Passive-aggressive
    Paternity Leave
    Paternity Leave Policy
    Pay Gap
    Pensions
    People Operations
    Poaching Employees
    Policy
    Problem Employee
    Productivity
    Profit
    Protected Disclosures Act
    Recruitment
    Redundancy
    Retirement
    Role Of HR
    Salary Transparency
    Sexual Harrassment
    Sick Leave
    Sick Pay
    Sick Policy
    Skills
    Skills Shortage
    Social Media
    Social Media Policy
    Staff Burnout
    Staff Engagement
    Staff Retention
    Staff Training
    Strategy
    Success
    Talent
    Talent Acquisition
    Talent Retention
    Team
    Teamwork
    Tech In HR
    The Jungle Book
    Training
    Trust
    Unfair Dismissal
    Vacation
    Whistleblower
    Work Arrangements
    Working Parents
    Workplace
    Workplace Bullying
    Workplace BYOD Policy
    Workplace Conflict
    Workplace Discrimination
    Workplace Harassment
    Workplace Health
    Work Related Stress
    Zero Hour Contract

    RSS Feed

HR Department, 49 Hollybank Avenue, Lower Ranelagh, Dublin 6, Ireland.
 
Phone : +353 (0)1 685 2360 Fax: +353 (0)1 685 2532 E-mail: info@thehrdepartment.ie

Registered in Ireland under company number 348834

Testimonials

Fallon and Byrne

“As a medium –sized business, we could not justify having an in-house HR person. The HR department provided the perfect solution for us, giving us access to all of the expert advice we needed on an outsourced basis"

READ MORE!
Website by Chevron Studio